Is a loose toilet a big deal?
firstchoice • January 1, 2021

January 1, 2021

Here’s an issue that we see in 90% of home inspections – Loose Toilets.

It sounds silly, but it’s true! We literally see this condition all the time!

So is this item a big deal in the great scheme of a home inspection? The answer is no – most of the time.

Usually, the fix is simply that the floor bolts just need to be re-tightened on each side of the toilet. This can be accomplished with just about any type of wrench and takes mere minutes to complete.

But occasionally, we run into a situation where the condition of the toilet being loose – usually for extended periods of time without being repaired, causes the toilet to be offset from the floor connection. There is a wax ring located at the base of the toilet that provides a gasket connection for the wastewater and solids to pass through.

Over many years, the wax ring can break down, which could cause leaking. But the condition of a loose toilet over time can also cause the toilet to become offset from the wax ring, which can also lead to leaking. This usually is from the simple rocking motion that people make when sitting on the toilet and/or getting up from it.

And over time you can end up with a scenario similar to the one that occurred in the pictures included here….

So I received a frantic phone call from a realtor friend of my wife who lives in Massachusetts, who suddenly noticed prominent water stains located on her kitchen ceiling.

My first question to her was, “Is there a bathroom located above the kitchen?”

The answer was yes.

So my direction to her was, “Please go upstairs and push on your toilet to see if it rocks back and forth.”

Lo and behold, the toilet was loose. In fact, it was very loose, rocking back and forth very noticeably she said!

So my next instruction was for her to tighten both of the floor bolts, which they promptly achieved.

And then I advised them to continue monitoring the kitchen ceiling, and if additional staining is noticed, at that point the wax ring under the toilet may need to be replaced.

Checking back with them a week later, they said they had not noticed any additional leaking.

But then they asked me how do they remove the stains located on the ceiling from the leak?

Well we’ll save that for the next blog!

 

Michael McCarty

NH Licensed Home Inspector # 316

HUD 203k Consultant # 1939

 

 

White ceiling with dark, linear water stains and a metal light fixture.
White ceiling with two faint, horizontal lines. Corner of a light blue object is visible on the right.
Water stain on a white ceiling, near a recessed light.
White ceiling with several dark spots; two pendant lights hang below.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

By firstchoice December 25, 2025
When does the home inspector invoke the dreaded Structural Engineer? In my career as a home inspector, I have probably only had to recommend a Structural Engineer about six times. So it doesn’t happen very often. In fact, when a home inspector says that a Structural Engineer is needed, it is typically the death nell […] The post When does the home inspector invoke the dreaded Structural Engineer? appeared first on First Choice Home Inspection.
By firstchoice December 25, 2025
Recently, I inspected a 150 year old home located exactly next to a busy road – a state highway in fact. When the house was first built, the road was only a dirt road, and only hosted horses and carriages. But over the years, the road was built up, encroaching ever closer to the house. […] The post Are there any issues with a house being located right next to a road? appeared first on First Choice Home Inspection.
By firstchoice February 11, 2025
Sorry I haven’t blogged in a while! We have been so busy this past year. Every month of 2024 set new records for home inspections. New Hampshirites can certainly claim that we live in an interesting state. The state motto of New Hampshire is “Live Free or Die.” Many that live here are very proud […] The post Home Inspectors vs. Code appeared first on First Choice Home Inspection.
Show More →